A message for the High Holidays
With the Jewish High Holidays of Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur here, many Jews reflect upon their Judaism, and the State of Israel, more now than at any other time of year. It’s a time of introspection and commitment to the year ahead. And with the election almost here, it’s a time when many Jews will be asking, “Which of these candidates would be best for Israel?”
What follows is…
- A brief recap of a presentation I attended the other night by Dr. Anthony Lake, Senior Foreign Policy Adviser to Barack Obama
- A summary of a pre-Rosh Hashana conference call Obama held recently with 900 rabbis
- A perspective on Obama from AIPAC
- A note about the Vice Presidential candidates
- Links/resources for more information
Pittsburgh presentation by Dr. Anthony Lake, Senior Foreign Policy Adviser to Barack Obama
Tony Lake (as he is more commonly known) appeared at Rodef Shalom Congregation Thursday evening, September 25, the night before the Presidential debate that was to focus on foreign policy. (The scheduling itself shows the importance the Obama campaign places on western Pennsylvania’s Jewish vote.) Lake was the United States National Security Adviser to President Clinton from 1993 to 1997 and has a long list of foreign policy achievements dating back to 1962, especially in the Middle East. His Wikipedia page lists his alma mater as Harvard and Princeton and his profession as “academician, diplomat, negotiator and political adviser.” It also lists his religion as Jewish.
Interestingly, Lake, one of several influential Jews with high-ranking positions in the Obama campaign, is a “Jew by choice,” a convert to Judaism. At the presentation Lake spoke of his personal history, the role that Judaism plays in his life, his time with the Clinton administration, and, most importantly, what attracted him to Barack Obama, why he sought him out, and why he joined the campaign.
In the presentation Lake said he is often asked, “Which candidate loves Israel more?” He said he couldn’t answer that. He said that if he didn’t truly feel, 100%, that Obama was deeply and unequivocally committed to the security of Israel that he could not have joined his campaign. He said that he also feels that John McCain is equally committed to Israel. He said the critical question is not, “Which candidate loves Israel more?” but “Which America is best for Israel?” He said that because of the horrible missteps of the Bush administration, particularly the ill-advised Iraq war, that hatred towards Israel and the U.S. has grown tremendously in the region. This has placed Israel in far more danger than before. His message was that the healthier, more economically sound, more respected America that an Obama presidency would bring is best for Israel.
He spoke about the value of Obama already being so respected and popular around the world. He asked the audience to raise their hands if they had been overseas in recent years, and mentioned how the feelings towards America, and Americans, had soured during the Bush administration. He specifically mentioned Obama’s trip to Europe over the summer, saying that seeing 200,000 people in Berlin coming to see him, waving American flags, was amazing, and that he would have been deeply impressed to see any candidate elicit such a response. Electing Obama would be seen worldwide as a clear, positive change from the destructive Bush policies, he said, and that will enable Obama to garner more international support for American positions, and American allies like Israel.
Lake also spoke about false accusations being spread on the internet about Obama (including the false claim that he is a Muslim), and warned that the smears will probably continue as a tactic to frighten voters.
Finally he spoke about the contrast between the temperament and judgement of the two candidates. McCain tends to be quick-tempered, inflammatory (singing about bombing Iran), and someone with a history of acting rashly. On the other hand, Obama is known for keeping his cool, gathering information, then acting decisively without panic. Lake pointed to both candidates’ behaviors during the Wall St. meltdown over the past two weeks as an example of how each man handles a crisis.
(See the end of this email for link to the Moment magazine article about Lake, which includes more info about Obama’s positions and Jewish members of his campaign.)
Obama and 900 rabbis on a recent conference call
On Wednesday, Sept. 17, Sen. Obama held a pre-Rosh Hashana conference call with 900 rabbis from around the country. During the call, four rabbis, one representing each of four major denominations–Orthodox, Conservative, Reform and Reconstructionist–were given the opportunity to ask questions. (One of the rabbis said it was “unprecedented” for a presidential candidate to hold such a call.) A friend of mine had the opportunity to listen in, and told me it was quite interesting…and exciting. According to her, Obama spoke at length and with ease and intelligence about a variety of subjects, especially Israel. Obama was highly regarded as a friend of the Jewish community during his years in the Illinois State senate, and his comfort with, and fondness for, the community showed in the phone call, she said. Two elements that struck a chord with her were his resolve towards protecting Israel from the threat from Iran, that he was very forceful on the subject, and second was something that was not addressed in the conference call but that she heard later in a program about Israel. The program spoke about the effect of the U.S. economy on Israel. The quote was, “When America gets a cold, Israel gets the flu.” Obama’s clear strength on economic issues (just ask supporters like Warren Buffett), therefore, is significant to Israel’s economic health and security.
(See the end for links to stories I found online about the conference call.)
The way AIPAC sees Obama
From an article in Moment magazine (link below): “Obama’s public record on Israel is as unblemished as that of Clinton and presumptive Republican nominee McCain, according to Harold Friedman, the president of American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), the influential American Jewish lobby. In its analysis of Obama, the National Jewish Democratic Council, which remained neutral in the primary race, reports that Obama co-sponsored the Palestinian Anti-Terrorism Act and signed several letters urging actions on behalf of Israel. One called on the European Union to add Hezbollah to its list of terrorist groups; another urged President George W. Bush to press Palestinian leadership to bar terrorist groups from Palestinian elections; and a third expressed solidarity with Israel in its fight against terrorism. The Council also reported that Obama voted multiple times in favor of aid to Israel and has led in the push for divestment from Iran by investors and state and local governments.”
The Vice Presidential candidates
Sen. Joe Biden
Sen. Biden, Chairman of the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, has a long track record of being a staunch supporter of Israel. No one, Democrat or Republican, questions his commitment or record.
I found this online:
“Remarks by Ambassador of Israel to the United States, David Ivry, at the Jewish National Fund 100th Anniversary Dinner honoring Sen. Joe Biden.”
http://www.israelemb.org/bios/Speeches/ivry/di02-03-11-2.html
Gov. Sarah Palin
Well, who knows? But here’s one perspective:
“Kissing the Jewish vote goodbye: Sarah Palin’s evangelical Christianity and perfunctory support for Israel are likely to turn off Jewish McCain supporters”
By Richard Silverstein
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2008/sep/04/uselections2008.sarahpalin3
Links & Resources
A wealth of information is on the “Jewish Americans” section of the Obama-Biden campaign website including a printable Israel fact sheet, a recent video of former U.S. Special Coordinator on the Middle East, Dennis Ross, speaking to Jewish community members in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, and an official statement by Obama regarding recent remarks by the Iranian president at the U.N.
http://my.barackobama.com/page/content/jahome
Jews4Obama.com
An independent site, some of which addresses “smear” campaigns against Obama.
www.jews4obama.com
“Obama is a strong friend of Israel” by Florida Congressman Robert Wexler in the Jersusalem Post.
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1203847477582&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FPrinter
An official campaign site designed to combat and correct lies and smears about Obama. Very well organized, with videos, links, etc.
www.fightthesmears.com
“The Conversions of Anthony Lake: How Bill Clinton’s National Security Advisor became an Obama-man—and a Jew.” Moment magazine, May/June 2008:
http://www.momentmag.com/Exclusive/2008/2008-05/200805-Lake.html
“Obama conference call with rabbis covers education, the meaning of the shofar, support for Israel.” The Jewish Journal, Sept. 17, 2008
http://www.jewishjournal.com/elections/article/obama_confe_20080917/
A personal perspective on the conference call by Rabbi Andy Bachman of Congregation Beth Elohim in Brooklyn.
http://www.andybachman.com/?p=862